
I just found out I have been missing out on the news about the recent Ansel Adams find. I saw it mentioned in the
Wall Street Journal yesterday and found more in depth info in the
LA Times here and
here.
For those as ignorant as me, a gentleman named Rick Norsigian in California purchased some glass plate negatives from a garage sale ten years ago and someone put a bug in his ear that they might be Ansel Adams' originals. He has spent the better part of the past decade trying to authenticate them. Apparently he has had difficulty getting photography and history scholars to authenticate them for whatever reason, so he hired his own authenticators, none of whom are experts on Ansel Adams. He also had them appraised at $200 million. Now he is selling prints to the public from his website. You can check out the prints
here.
I have to admit, I am skeptical about this for a lot of reasons. Everyone living who was close to Adams claims that the negatives are not his work. I am no expert, but I am an Adams fan and the images don't look like Adams' work to me. They look like black and white photos taken from standard Yosemite photo spots by a talented amateur. And, as it turns out, they may just be the work of a talented amateur. A woman in California has
come forward, saying that the photos were taken by her uncle and she has prints that apparently match the negatives. Hopefully both her prints and Norsigian's negatives will be put into the hands of someone with some expertise in this area and it will all get sorted out.
I don't think that Mr. Norsigian is lying or trying to be dishonest about this. I suspect that he really believes they are Adams' work and also likes the idea of making some money off of them. Admitting that after all of this time and effort that they are not really Adam's work would be a crushing ego blow. But, if they are not in fact Adams', the world has a right to know.
One interesting side note: if people enjoy looking at the photos, does it really matter if Adams made them or not? Here is a link to the
WSJ article that got me started on this and discusses that very subject.